1 Introduction
2 Review
3 Methods
3.1 Academic genealogy fecundity
3.2 Academic influence forces of academic genealogy
3.2.1 Scales of individual academic influence forces
3.2.2 Academic influence forces of different generations
3.2.3 Total academic influence forces of academic genealogy
3.2.4 Contribution of individual members to the academic influence forces of academic genealogy I
3.3 Two-dimensional evaluation system for the academic genealogy
Table 1 Indices in the two-dimensional evaluation system for academic genealogy. |
First grade indexes | Second grade indexes | Investigation content |
---|---|---|
academic fecundity | A: Summed number of times an individual has served as an advisor on a dissertation | Reflects the number of students trained by that mentor. |
T: Total number of descendants in an individual's family tree | Reflects the total number of disciples in the genealogy. | |
G:Summed number of generations of descendants of an individual | Reflects the number of generations of academic genealogy reproduction. | |
W: Total number of descendants in the largest generation in an individual's family tree | Reflects the most prosperous generation status of the academic genealogy. | |
TA: Total number of descendants in an individual's family tree who went on to become advisors themselves | Reflects the number of members with inheritance ability in the genealogy. | |
TD: Calculates the decaying influence of descendants in an individual's family tree | Reflects the general situation of the number of members in the academic genealogy from the first generation. | |
academic influence forces | i: Individual academic influence forces | Reflects the outstanding academic individuals in the genealogy. |
J: Academic influence forces of different generations | Reflects the outstanding generation in the genealogy. | |
R: Total academic influence forces of an academic genealogy | Reflects the academic status of the genealogy. | |
I: Contribution of individual members to the academic influence forces of an academic genealogy | Reflects a member's contribution to the academic influence of the genealogy. |
4 Results and discussion
4.1 Liu Tungsheng's profile
4.2 Liu Tungsheng's academic genealogy
Table 2 Structure of the Liu Tungsheng academic genealogy. |
First generation | Second generation (46) | Third generation (217) | |
---|---|---|---|
Liu Tungsheng Liu Tungsheng | post-doctoral (10) | Guo Zhengtang (21) | PhD (15): Wu Haibin*, Dai Ying*, Wu Chunlin, Xiaou Goqiao, Ge Junyi, Yao Zhengquan, Wei Jianjing, Guo Qingzhen, Yin Qiuzhen, Zhang Zhongshi*, Liu Jinfeng, Peng Shuzhen, Qiao Yansong, Zhang Yan*, Chang Lin; Master (6): Zhou Xin, Zhao De'ai, Liang Meiyan, Yu Yanyan, Sun bin, Yao Xiaofeng |
Qin Xiaoguang (4) | PhD (2): Mu Yan* Zhang Lei; Master (2): Wu Jinshui, Yin Zhiqiang | ||
Tan Ming (4) | PhD (2): Hou Juzhi*, Duan Wuhui; Master (2): Tian Lijun, Tao Tao | ||
Xiao Jule (7) | PhD (3): Yan Jia, Si Bin, Li Yuecong*; Master (4): Liang Wendong, Zhou Lang*, Wu Jintao, Li Hongmei | ||
Li Yumei (3) | Master (3): Tao Qianye, Wang Lixian*, Sun Fengrui | ||
Yang Xiaoyan (2) | Post-doctoral (1): Li Quan*; Master (1): Wan Zhiwei | ||
Wang Qian, Zhao Hua, Cai Binggui, Paul D. White | |||
Ph.D. (28) | Sun Jimin (10) | PhD (4): Yang Lirong*, Lv Tongyan, Liu Bin, Shi Caidong*, Lin Xu, Zhang Jilaing; Master (4): Gong Yingzeng, Huang Xiaogang, Han Peng*, Sun Gaoyuan | |
Liu Jiaqi (20) | Post-doctoral (1): Cao Yu*; PhD (17): Sui Shuzhen, He Huaiyu, Dong Dong*, Li Xin*, Xu Kejian, Liu Yalei*, Sui Jianli, Liu Wenye, Huang Shiyan*, Ni Yunyan, Ma Shuopeng, Zhang Nianfu*, Mu Yan*, Liu Qiang, Wang Wenyuan, Zhong Hua*, Cai Chuanqiang; Master (2):Zhang Guoping, Song Chunyu | ||
Ding Zhongli (19) | Post-doctoral (5): Wu Fuli, Yang Shengli, Tian Jun, Du Shuisheng, Zhao Hua; PhD (10): Yang Shiling*, Wang Xu*, Jiang Hanchao, Ji Junliang, Chen Zuoling, Xie Jing*, Yang Lirong*, Zhao Shujun, Hou Shengshan, Dong Xinxin; Master (4): Gao Ling, Zhou Bin, Ding Feng, Chen Zhuo | ||
Zhu Zhaoyu (12) | PhD (11): Ouyang Tingping*, Jiang Bo*, Liang Chunge, Xie Jiubing, Zhao Shengli, Yang Tian, Sun Bo, Fu Shuqing*, Su Ruixia, Xu Ruisong, Qiu Shifan; Master (1): Tian Chengjing | ||
Nie Gaozhong (3) | PhD (1): Zhang Shimin; Master (2): Deng Yan, Liang Fang | ||
Xiong Shangfa (3) | PhD (1): Lu Haijian, Master (2): Zhou Ru, Yang Ping | ||
Lv Houyuan (4) | PhD (3): Wang Shuyun, Zuo Xinxin; Dong Yajie;Master (1):Jia Jiwei | ||
Yu Kefu (7) | PhD (7): Yan Hongqiang*, Pan Wenliang*, Chen Tianran, Zhang Huiling, Li Shu, Zhao Meixia*, Huang Bojin; Master (5): Tian Cuicui, Zhou Jie*, Xiao Jinjun*, Lin Ziyun*, Huang Lingying | ||
Hou Juzhi (1) | Master (1): Zhang Wenjing* | ||
Liu Xiuming (5) | Master (5): Li Pingyuan, Liu Zhi, Guo Hui, Feng Hua, Ma Mingming | ||
Jiang Wenying (2) | Master (2): Cheng Yufen, Yang Xiaoxiao | ||
Zhu Rixiang (26) | Post-doctoral (5): Lv Lianqing, Shi Yonghong, He Huaiyu, Li Yumei, Wang Fei; PhD (20): Wang Hongqiang, Ge Shulan, Liu Jian, Yao Haitao, Shu Mengting, Wang Yongcheng, Li shihu, Shen Xiaoli, Liu Chengying, Shi Ruiping, Zhang Benhua, Huang Sheng, Ge Kunpeng, Li Xin, Shi Caidong, Qin Huafeng, Song Shujun, Tian Lili, Cai Shuhui, Liu Shangchi; Master (1): Xiao Bo | ||
Chen Yue, Li Feng, Cong Shaoguang, He Deming, Ren Jianzhang, Wang Zhenhai, Zhong Hua, Luo Yunli, Wang Xianfeng, Jin Guiyun, Wang Luo, Wu Wenxiang, Wang Daojing, Zhang song, Jin Chunsheng, Liu Ping | |||
Master (8) | An Zhisheng (41) | PhD (31): Zeng Cheng, Tan Liangcheng*, Zhang Xiaoye, Fu Chaofeng*, Xu Xinwen*, Ning Youfeng*, Liu Bin*, Wang Sheng*, Liu Suixin*, Ai Li*, Zhang Haiwei*, Dong Jibao, Lu Fengyan, Li Hongkai, Kang Shugang*, Zhan Changlin*, Wang Jin*, Dong Jungang*, Han Yongming*, Lan Jianghu*, Zhang Fan*, Li Zhenghua, Lu Huayu, Zhao Jiangtao*, Sun Qianli*, Wu Feng*, Zhu Chongshu*, Sun Donghuai, Zhang Peng, Xu Tingting, Li Yun Master (10): Tan Liuqin*, Hu Weiguo*, He Liu*, Liu Xiaoyan*, Hou Zhaohua*, Zhang Ling*, Lin Benmei, Jiang Yi*, Ren Jianzhang, Guo Panlin* | |
Zhao Xitao (1) | Master (1): Li Bo | ||
Jia Rongfen (1) | PhD (1): Peng Xianzhi * | ||
Han Jiamao (2) | PhD (1): Wang Guoan; Master (1): Chu Jun | ||
Han Jingtai (6) | PhD (4): Li Dong, Wang Daojing*, Chen Hehai, Sun Huiguo Master (2): Wu Lei, Dai Guoliang | ||
Gu Zhaoyan (5) | PhD (2): Yang Shiling, Liu Zongxiu; Master (3): Wang Pan, Hu Bin, Zhou Qian | ||
Zheng Hongbo (11) | Post-doctoral (3): Liu Lianwen, Zhou Bin, Zhang Xinrong; PhD (2): Huang Xiangtong, Yang Wenguang; Master (6): Ji Junliang, Qing Ziqi, Liu Rui, Chen Guocheng, Wang Ke, Mei Xi* | ||
Xu Li |
Note: “*” indicates that the student was jointly cultivated by two or more mentors. The number in the parenthesis is the number of disciples. The number of third-generation disciples is constantly increasing. Therefore, our data is untill 2015. |
4.3 Fecundity analysis of Liu Tungsheng academic genealogy
Table 3 Fecundity analysis parameters of the Liu Tungsheng academic genealogy. |
Indicators | Liu Tungsheng | Implication |
---|---|---|
A | 46 | Liu Tungsheng trained 46 graduate students. |
T | 263 | This genealogy has a current total of 263 disciples. |
G | 2 | This genealogy has two generations of disciples. |
W | 217 | The largest number of disciples is 217 in the third generation. |
TA | 26 | There are 26 mentors in the genealogy. |
TD | 154.5 | Liu Tungsheng's contribution to the genealogy reproduction is 154.5. |
4.4 Academic influence forces of Liu Tungsheng's academic genealogy
Table 4 Academic influences forces of different generations of the Liu Tungsheng academic genealogy. |
First-generation influence (J1) | Second-generation influence (J2) | Third-generation influence (J3) | General influence of academic genealogy |
---|---|---|---|
20.05 (1) | 348.22 (46) | 361.79 (217) | 730.06 |
Table 5 Academic influence forces of members in Liu Tungsheng academic genealogy and their contribution to academic genealogy. |
1G member | Contribution to academic genealogy | 2G Member | Individual academic influence | Contribution to academic genealogy | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Liu Tungsheng | 20.05+(120.35+ 303.22+129.33)/2 = 20.05+552.9/2 = 296.5 | Post- doctor | Guo Zhengtang | 22.09 | 51.39 |
Qin Xiaoguang | 6 | 9.69 | |||
Tan Ming | 6.49 | 11.98 | |||
Xiao Jule | 14.25 | 23.03 | |||
Li Yumei | 1.58 | 2.08 | |||
Yang Xiaoyan | 5.32 | 7.73 | |||
Wang Qian | 4.86 | 4.86 | |||
Zhao Hua | 5.25 | 5.25 | |||
Cai Binggui | 4.37 | 4.37 | |||
Paul D. White | 0 | 0 | |||
Ph.D. | Sun Jimin | 21.59 | 29.98 | ||
Liu Jiaqi | 7 | 18.07 | |||
Ding Zhongli | 20.85 | 47.57 | |||
Zhu Zhaoyu | 4.21 | 14.18 | |||
Nie Gaozhong | 1.43 | 4.645 | |||
Xiong Shangfa | 8.47 | 9.78 | |||
Lv Houyuan | 21.87 | 24.67 | |||
Yu Kefu | 12.33 | 16.56 | |||
Hou Juzhi | 7.18 | 8.66 | |||
Liu Xiuming | 16.35 | 17.97 | |||
Jiang Wenying | 6.96 | 8.83 | |||
Zhu Rixiang | 21.22 | 33.04 | |||
Chen Yue | 2.8 | 2.8 | |||
Li Feng | 8.66 | 8.66 | |||
Cong Shaoguang | 2.86 | 2.86 | |||
He Deming | 0 | 0 | |||
Ren Jianzhang | 6.36 | 6.36 | |||
Wang Zhenhai | 1 | 1 | |||
Zhong Hua | 3.4 | 3.4 | |||
Luo Yunli | 4.82 | 4.82 | |||
Wang Xianfeng | 10.29 | 10.29 | |||
Jin Guiyun | 2.33 | 2.33 | |||
Wang Luo | 1.55 | 1.55 | |||
Wu Wenxiang | 5.51 | 5.51 | |||
Wang Daojing | 4.26 | 4.26 | |||
Zhang song | 1.7 | 1.7 | |||
Jin Chunsheng | 5.24 | 5.24 | |||
Liu Ping | 8.5 | 8.5 | |||
Master | An Zhisheng | 21.26 | 62.42 | ||
Zhao Xitao | 2.67 | 2.67 | |||
Jia Rongfen | 2.96 | 8.08 | |||
Han Jiamao | 8.02 | 8.02 | |||
Han Jingtai | 6.68 | 14.93 | |||
Gu Zhaoyan | 6.97 | 12.88 | |||
Zheng Hongbo | 10.71 | 20.34 | |||
Xu Li | 4.78 | 0 |